This year has been peculiar in real estate. Obviously, prices are down in all categories. Obviously, short sales and foreclosures are featured on many buyers’ dance cards. And obviously, the market is suffering from a negative feedback loop fed by the media. I spend all day, every day, talking with prospective buyers, prospective sellers, and contemplative owners of real estate. Early in the year, buyers were ALL talking about how they anticipated interest rates would go down to 3% (and some buyers were insisting that rates would go even lower). I would just nod my head and concede that was a possibility. After all, what do I know about the unknowable? But, I always pointed out that whatever rates fell to, you could never know the bottom until it was gone. And that rates would surely go back up again — I was not going out on a limb; every economist on Earth is saying the same thing. Sure enough, since my last report, interest rates have jumped up almost a full point and the forecast does not look as though rates will fall back to the levels buyers were talking about just a short 2 months ago (let alone where they were three weeks ago). Meanwhile, it seems buyers are picking up on the FACT that rates are likely to climb and they are out in droves.
Predictably, the low end is getting the most attention. In Novato, 72% of homes priced under $500,000 are in escrow (that’s 44 out of 60 homes!). In San Rafael, 64% of homes priced at or below $600,000 are in escrow (that’s 29 out of 45!). Incredibly, 11 homes in Novato sold last month under $400K, 9 more sold under $500K, and another 11 sold under $600K. That’s 31 Novato homes selling under $600K. Three years ago, under $600K, you would see perhaps 3 or 4 for homes on the market at any given time. These sales are propelled by value, the $8,000 tax credit, and the increased FHA loan limits which went into effect in April 2009. I had 3 listings sell in late May and early June via FHA loans.
Standing back and looking at the higher price bands (especially in Southern Marin), things look a little different. Some sellers still suffer from pricing strategies that prevent them from realistically engaging with qualified buyers. These sellers are either: 1) NOT Sellers; or 2) are getting poor advice and direction from their agents. They will learn that "time on the market" is not their friend. Being a “smart seller” today means negotiating strong terms aimed towards a successful close of escrow within 30 days. Some sellers feel being the “smartest in the room” means either attempting to control the Buyer, and/or over-pricing, and/or countering offers in a way that evidences their desire to single-handedly change Marin County’s real estate market dynamics. While "one-in-a-million" buyers may exist, no buyer will pay $1 million for an $750K home. Indeed, we don’t see anybody offering $50 for a share of Citibank….
Changing gears, given current trades numbers, escrows, and open house activity, it seems likely that the traditional Summer slowdown in home sales will be modest as buyers continue pursuing those "value" properties. There is a sea of pent-up demand out there. The chart below shows a 90-day rolling average of Mill Valley’s new listings and absorbed listings (e.g., sales), comparing current numbers with those of last year. Note that the while the numbers for new listings are about the same, the number of absorbed listings is about equal to 2008. If you would like to review a similar chart for any other town or city in Marin or San Francisco, please let me know.

Inventory build-up is evident; we have 902 single family homes for sale (there were 830 last month and 643 in April) in the Highway 101 corridor (this number excludes Western Marin and beach community inventory as well as condos). Open houses this past Sunday were extraordinarily busy in all price ranges. While the upper end has shown sluggish sales, I am certain that there are buyers out there who are simply waiting for some sign from on high that the time to buy has arrived. Although, I don’t have the foggiest idea what form that sign may take. As always, well priced, updated homes in great locations are selling promptly.
The following table breaks down the current number of homes for sale and price ranges in Marin County’s HWY 101 corridor (e.g., Marin’s coastal communities are not included) in June 2009, along with the price ranges for each town and/or city.
|
Town/City
|
Homes for Sale
(Active Listings)
|
Price Range
|
|
Sausalito
|
33
|
$349,000-$18 million
|
|
Belvedere
|
33
|
$1.95 million-$14.85 million
|
|
Tiburon
|
75
|
$810,000-$24.9 million
|
|
Mill Valley
|
142
|
$390,000-$6.5 million
|
|
Larkspur
|
32
|
$750,000-$2.895 million
|
|
Corte Madera
|
27
|
$685,000-$3.6 million
|
|
Greenbrae
|
16
|
$840,000-$3.295 million
|
|
Kentfield
|
41
|
$875,000-$9.995 million
|
|
Ross
|
26
|
$895,000-$17.5 million
|
| Fairfax |
30 |
$535,000-$2.195 million |
|
San Anselmo
|
60
|
$525,000-$2.995 million
|
|
San Rafael
|
167
|
$341,000-$4.9 million
|
|
Novato
|
136
|
$299,000-$4.2 million
|
At the request of a reporter for the London Financial Times, I recently put together some "year-to-date" numbers relating to the Marin County real estate market and compared them with last year’s numbers from the same period. The results were interesting and striking.
Between 1/1/08 and 6/11/08, we had 654 sales. Here are the averages from that period: Days on Market = 85, Price = $1.387 million, and Price Per Square Foot = $581.
Between 1/1/09 and 6/11/09, we had 537 sales (down 18%). The averages were: Days on Market = 110 (up 23%), Price = $958K (down 31%), and Price Per Square Foot = $453 (down 22%). These numbers are harsh. Yet, how to interpret them depends on your weltanschauung. It seems to me that people tend to see what they want to see and that no matter what the numbers say, interpretation is akin to a
Rorschach inkblot test. Indeed, some will see those numbers and want to buy now and others will see them and want to sell now.
For a detailed executive summary providing statistics and trends relating to the Marin real estate market (or any specific zip code), please call me any time (I am Kyle Frazier, Marin Realtor & CRS, Morgan Lane Marin Real Estate) at (415) 350-9440 or e-mail me at
Kyle@NorthBayRE.com. It is always my pleasure to be of service.